Irish oatmeal cooked with milk and topped with brown sugar. [Photographs: Vicky Wasik]

The whole lot you should make a very powerful meal of the day scrumptious.
Each fall, 25 worldwide rivals pack into the group heart in Carrbridge, a small city nestled up within the Scottish Highlands, to go head-to-head in a grueling competitors that requires each day coaching, which in lots of instances they’ve undertaken for a lot of their lives. The principles are strict, their instruments spartan, and the target grandiose but humble—be named World Porridge Champion. This have to be achieved with nothing greater than oats, water, and salt.
Like I mentioned, it is grueling.
It is arduous to think about the way it’s doable to differentiate oneself with so few components in play. Assuming the rivals aren’t such dangerous cooks that they current a bowl as skinny as soup or as thick as cement, how a lot distinction can there be from one entry to the subsequent? I am so perplexed by this that I ship an e-mail to the World Porridge Championship. Quickly I am on the cellphone with considered one of their judges, the chef Lydie Bocquillon, and I obtain a separate e-mail from Martyn O’Reilly, the resident grasp of ceremonies. (He’s, on the time, en path to Munich to advise its native porridge championship after which off to Warsaw to host a Burns Supper; the lifetime of a porridge MC is way more attention-grabbing than I guessed).
“We find yourself tasting in all probability 40 odd bowls of conventional porridge,” Bocquillon tells me, “And I can actually say they’re very totally different from each other.” Rivals are exacting, she says. They usually convey their very own water, even internationally, and choose their salt with equal care. Bocquillon, who’s initially from France, says that as a lot as she loves sel de Guérande from her fatherland, it is too harsh for oatmeal. “With porridge you want one thing a bit extra delicate. You don’t put rather a lot in if you cook dinner the oatmeal, only a pinch, after which flake just a little on prime.”
The oats are, after all, paramount. They have to be floor in metal or stone mills to make a pinhead or finer particle measurement; neither rolled nor prompt oats, that are parcooked and processed for fast comfort, are eligible.
Then there are the issues folks do this sound close to superstitious. The stirring utensil is chosen with care, and even the pace, frequency, and course of stirring could be chosen intentionally. Some declare the porridge have to be stirred with the correct hand solely in a clockwise course, which I feel we are able to dismiss immediately as nonsense.
As for O’Reilly, he tells me he is eaten the oatmeal made by all of the finalists yearly since 2006, and he is concluded “the winners have all stirred their porridge for the total half hour to make it very easy and have boiled it all the way down to get a easy combination, not too thick to stay to the spoon however sufficient to have the ability to pour it out relatively than spoon it out.”
They’ve me intrigued. I’ve cooked oatmeal on and off for a lot of my life, and I’ve at all times been happy with the outcomes, however they’ve given it extra consideration than I assumed doable. It was time to do my very own checks and unlock no matter secrets and techniques I may to seek out the most effective strategies for the best bowl of morning oats.
Sorts of Oats for Oatmeal
Most of the phrases used for oatmeal are synonymous—pinhead oats, steel-cut oats, and Irish oats all describe very coarsely cracked groats (the phrase for hulled oats).
Oatmeal itself could be a complicated phrase. In america, it usually refers back to the cooked porridge, whereas in the UK, it describes a meal (i.e., flour) constructed from oats; what you cook dinner that oatmeal into is porridge. Oatmeal within the flour sense could be floor coarse, medium, or superb, historically on milling stones, which is why you will generally see it described as “stone-ground.”
Past which might be rolled oats, which have been softened and parcooked by steam after which rolled flat to lower their thickness and enhance their floor space, all of which speeds cooking. Fast-cooking oats and prompt oats are merely variations on the rolled-oats course of, however they’re made even thinner for a fair shorter cooking time. (You possibly can learn extra about oats in our complete grain information.)
I’ve no objection to these merchandise, however I did not check them for this text. They’re comfort meals that cook dinner up rapidly and simply and require much less rationalization than the long-cooking steel-cut/pinhead oats that I’m specializing in right here. What I need is a bowl of nutty oats that retain a barely chewy texture with out seeming undercooked; the feel must be neither dry and stiff nor overly moist and soupy. Something that hastens the method with out undermining the flavour and texture is a plus.
Spurtles, Spons, Porringers, and Pots: The Instruments of the Commerce
A spurtle.
The winner of the World Porridge Championship annually wins the Golden Spurtle, a trophy of the cooking implement—actually it is only a glorified stick—the Scottish have used for hundreds of years to stir their oats as they cook dinner. There’s loads of lore across the spurtle. Some declare that as a result of it lacks a spoon’s broad bowl, it agitates the porridge much less throughout cooking and yields a greater texture.
I discover such claims arduous to imagine, however I purchased one anyway simply to strive it out. It seems I will make porridge simply as effectively with a picket spoon as with the spurtle, so whereas I loved the novelty of utilizing one, and of claiming the foolish identify as usually as I may to everybody I may, you don’t want it.
I do, nonetheless, take pleasure in being a pedant about spurtles. If you are going to personal one, you would possibly as effectively personal the correct one. Many web sites right now confuse the spatula-like Couthie spurtle, which is used for issues like flipping oatcakes, with the dowel-like spurtle, which is the one meant for porridge. It might be terribly embarrassing to go to the difficulty of procuring a spurtle solely to finish up ignorantly stirring your morning porridge with an oatcake flipper, would not it?
Past spurtles are some hybrid implements just like the spon, which is a spoon-spurtle mashup made by a former World Porridge champion. Bocquillon tells me it is pleasant for making porridge, and I imagine her, however I nonetheless will not get one. I can barely use a spurtle with a straight face, its storied Scottish historical past the one factor conserving me from utilizing it as kindling, however a spon? That’s too absurd to contemplate. A picket spoon will suffice.
Oh, however there’s extra. Ever hear of a porringer? It is an actual factor, I swear, and it’s nothing greater than a fancy-sounding double-boiler, besides…primarily for porridge. There’s nothing flawed with utilizing a double boiler for cooking a thick substance like oatmeal, because it reduces the possibilities of it unintentionally sticking and scorching, particularly when you’re busy within the kitchen and may’t maintain your eye absolutely on the oats, however you in any other case don’t want one. Even on the championship, an occasion so porridge-obsessed nobody bats an eye fixed at a spurtle or a spon, it is usually agreed that making a porringer an everyday fixture of 1’s oatmeal technique is, as Bocquillon put it, “a bit pompous.”
Extra useful than something, in my view, is to make use of a sloped-sided pot, just like the three-quart saucier we often advocate. The curved corners on the backside of the pot are simple to scrape clear with a spoon, decreasing the probabilities the oatmeal scorches the place your spoon cannot attain.

The Extra You Stir…
Certainly one of my first checks was to seek out out simply how essential stirring, or not stirring, is. I made a number of batches of steel-cut oats, stirring some quickly and continually, some slowly and continually, and a few solely as little as wanted to stop sticking. I used spoons and my spurtle.
Stirring, I discovered, does matter. The extra and the quicker I stirred the oatmeal, the thicker and gluier it turned. The reason being clear: The extra the oats are agitated within the pot, the extra starch is knocked free from the grain and into the encircling liquid, thickening it. It is not a lot {that a} spurtle makes a noticeable distinction over a picket spoon, nevertheless it’s actually sufficient to be conscious to not overwork the combination. It’s possible you’ll sow your wild oats, however do not thrash them.
Tasters’ opinions differed on which they preferred most. I loved the least starchy model, which had what I can solely describe as a juicy texture, with distinct oat grains suspended in a creamy sauce, not in contrast to an excellent risotto. Others preferred the center model, stirred often however slowly; it was extra thick however nonetheless not stodgy. Nobody pointed to the quickly and continually stirred oatmeal as a favourite; as Golidlocks might need mentioned, that oatmeal was simply too thick.
I additionally examined a pair batches of oats that I rinsed earlier than cooking, to scrub off extra starch, however I did not see an enormous distinction between these and those that went straight into the pot with out rinsing.
Toasted Oats
Toasting the oats earlier than cooking them is a step some folks love to do, so I in contrast oatmeal constructed from dry-toasted oats, butter-toasted oats, and untoasted oats. Many higher-quality steel-cut oats available on the market come already calmly toasted, however the impact is delicate. Toasting the oats extra deeply can increase their taste. It is fairly good.
Almost everybody who tasted these batches blind most well-liked the dry-toasted oats, which I had cooked in a dry pan, tossing often, till they smelled very aromatic. Those toasted in butter ended up with what a number of tasters described as a popcorn taste, which all of them agreed was one thing that may change into overwhelming after a spoonful or two.
I used to be curious simply how a lot toasting would possibly deactivate the starches and affect thickening, which is one thing we all know occurs with each risotto and roux, however my checks did not yield any apparent outcomes. Toasting could effectively reduce starch’s thickening energy however not a lot that I used to be in a position to discover it.
Toast for taste, if you would like, however do not depend on it to change the oatmeal’s texture.
Water Ratios and the Sequence of Occasions
Oatmeal recipes counsel wherever from two to 4 components liquid per one half steel-cut oats. I performed with the ratios and located that many can work. It relies upon each on the oats themselves, since totally different merchandise can differ in grind measurement, and one’s private desire for the feel of the oats; a extra al dente chew requires much less liquid.
I ultimately settled on a 3:1 ratio of liquid to oats for many functions, however with the understanding that you could be want so as to add an extra dose of liquid if the oatmeal hits its goal thickness earlier than the oats have softened sufficient.
I discovered comparable flexibility with the sequence of occasions. I cooked some batches by sprinkling the oats into boiling water, as many bundle instructions say to do, and a few by combining the oats with chilly liquid after which bringing the combination as much as a simmer. I discovered no distinction between the new begin and chilly begin, which tracks with my polenta checks from a number of years in the past.
In a single day Oats Success
One of many most important downsides of utilizing steel-cut oats is that they take longer to cook dinner than rolled and prompt oats—upward of 20 minutes, which isn’t one thing we’re at all times within the temper to do, and even have the time to do, very first thing within the morning.
The frequent workaround is to soak the oats in a single day to totally hydrate them. All that is left within the morning is to warmth them up lengthy sufficient to gelatinize the starch and thicken the porridge up, which occurs in a matter of minutes.
The query was which of the most well-liked in a single day strategies was greatest. I attempted three: an in a single day soak adopted by cooking within the soaking water; an in a single day soak with the soaking water drained, the grains rinsed, after which cooked in recent water; and the grains and water mixed in a pot, dropped at a boil, coated, after which left to sit down in a single day and be reheated within the morning.
I attempted this with a pair totally different pinhead oat merchandise, together with some Scottish oats from an outdated water mill and the oats from Bob’s Purple Mill (Bob, it is value mentioning, is a two-time World Porridge Championship winner).
To my shock, I had very totally different outcomes with every sort. The in a single day Scottish oats had been nearly all practically inedible, with an disagreeable raw-dough taste that refused to go away even with a prolonged simmer. The one pattern from that batch of oats that was good was the one the place I had drained the soaking water, rinsed the grains, after which cooked them in recent water. I figured the issue was that in a single day soaking launched an excessive amount of starch into the water, and its taste was too robust to cook dinner off.
However once I repeated the check with Bob’s oats, the outcomes shifted. The perfect oats from that batch had been those that had been soaked after which cooked of their soaking liquid. Those I drained and rinsed took eternally to thicken sufficiently, nearing doneness at about the identical price as a pot of oats cooked straight from dry.
My greatest guess as to why the manufacturers assorted by way of which of the soaked samples got here out greatest could should do with how the oats had been processed. The Scottish oats had been floor on stones and had a barely extra powdery high quality; this additional starch could have been an excessive amount of for a fundamental in a single day soak with out draining and altering the soaking water first. Bob’s steel-cut oats, then again, are extra cleanly lower and fewer powdery, making the draining and rinsing steps pointless.
You will have to check your personal oats to determine which technique is greatest primarily based on them. The excellent news is there is a technique that works both manner, and it produces nice outcomes that make the in a single day trick value utilizing.
The oats that I dropped at a boil the night time earlier than after which left coated, in the meantime, weren’t nice no matter model. The outcomes appeared weirdly overcooked in texture, but undercooked in taste. Additionally they took longer to reheat due to how thick they’d grown in a single day, slowing down a lot of the time-savings; thinning with water to hurry reheating simply meant having to cook dinner the porridge longer to get it again to an excellent texture. It is not a technique I would advocate.
Typically, in comparison with unsoaked oats, in a single day oats are extra tender with a nice pop of every grain. I just like the chew of unsoaked grains, so I will nonetheless skip the in a single day soak generally too.
Milk Versus Water and Toppings to Take into account
Some could also be questioning why the cooking liquid itself is coming up to now down on this article. It has, arguably, much more dramatic outcomes than many of the different particulars I’ve talked about. It is for 2 causes: First, as a result of most individuals already know whether or not they fall into the water or milk camp, and so they do not want me to inform them what the variations are (in case you do not, the distinction is creamy or ultracreamy). And second, as a result of water is what the Scots historically used to cook dinner the oats (if being decadent, cream or butter can go on prime of a serving bowl however usually not within the porridge pot), and the Scots know their oatmeal.
That, mentioned, utilizing milk isn’t remarkable, particularly not right now when porridge is so usually made ultrarich and sweetened to the purpose of being dessert—scrumptious, however not one thing that retains it wholesome as a each day repast. The Irish appear to have discovered an excellent center floor, utilizing water or milk (or some mixture) to cook dinner the oats after which calmly sprinkling some brown sugar on prime.
For toppings, candy issues come to thoughts, whether or not syrups or jams, uncooked or poached fruits. Nuts and nut butters make each good toppings and mix-ins, and a dollop of thick bitter cream or yogurt may even work.
Simply pretty much as good however far much less usually thought of in america, the place oatmeal is routinely drowned in sugar, is to take a extra savory method. Mixing a uncooked egg in on the finish in order that it gently cooks within the oatmeal’s residual warmth is scrumptious, as are mix-ins like sautéed mushrooms, hearty greens, and grated cheese. Suppose shrimp and grits however with oats.
In the long run, the recipes I am giving listed here are essentially the most fundamental—Scottish-style oats cooked with water and a pinch of salt and topped with some butter or cream if you would like, together with a barely extra decadent Irish-style bowl of oats cooked with some milk and topped with brown sugar. Use them as jumping-off factors, then go wild. Who is aware of, possibly in the future you will be named the world’s greatest porridge-maker. If not that, we are able to all a minimum of aspire to the title at house.

This submit could comprise hyperlinks to Amazon or different companions; your purchases through these hyperlinks can profit Critical Eats. Learn extra about our affiliate linking coverage.