[Photographs: Vicky Wasik]
Those that’ve sampled their method via the chocolate desserts in my cookbook or right here on Severe Eats could have seen a pattern—my recipes nearly universally name for Dutch-process cocoa powder.
To completely respect the why, it is vital to grasp what cocoa powder is: the mass of dry matter left behind after the oily cocoa butter is extracted from cocoa beans which have been fermented and roasted for max taste. This powder is of course acidic. Pure cocoa powder is bought as is, whereas Dutched cocoas embody a further step to neutralize that acidity (a course of developed by a Dutch chemist, therefore the identify).
Cocoas inside every model can differ wildly in taste relying on the kind of cocoa bean used, the place it was grown, its high quality, how lengthy it was fermented, how darkly it was roasted, and the way a lot of its fats was eliminated (and, in Dutch kinds, the particular diploma of alkalization). That implies that the flavour, shade, fats content material, and pH of any cocoa powder will differ from model to model and elegance to model.
An assortment of pure cocoas.
Broadly talking, the pure cocoas bought in American supermarkets have a tendency to come back from mediocre cocoa beans which have had nearly all of their cocoa butter eliminated, leading to a light-red powder that is starchy and low in fats—about as wealthy and splendid as a handful of chalk. The acidity typically has a tinny high quality, fairly than one which’s zippy and shiny.
An assortment of Dutch cocoas.
However as a result of Dutch-style cocoa is perceived as a specialty product that may be bought at the next worth, most Dutch-cocoa manufacturers include almost twice the fats of pure kinds, and infrequently come from better-quality beans. The result’s a barely alkaline cocoa powder that is greater in fats, decrease in starch, and extra fragrant throughout, with a mahogany shade and a taste profile that emphasizes cocoa’s darker, nuttier, earthier tones.
Prior to now, calling for Dutch cocoa was my method of nudging bakers towards higher-quality components, guaranteeing that brownies and muffins bake up moist and wealthy, loaded with cocoa butter and a deep chocolate taste. However that is to not say all Dutch cocoas are equally wealthy and scrumptious, or that every one pure kinds are low-fat and bland.
Search round on-line, and you will find loads of pure cocoas that retain the next proportion of cocoa butter and are available from top-quality beans with a fantastically shiny acidity. I included 5 of them in an summary of my favourite pure cocoas.
Likewise, there are crappy Dutch cocoas on the market, created from low-quality beans which have been squeezed dry to take away each final drop of cocoa butter, then alkalized to the purpose of tasting extra like ash than chocolate. Others nonetheless could also be solely half alkalized, which might throw off the chemistry of a recipe that was developed for a real Dutch cocoa.
So here is a group of Dutch cocoas that I can personally vouch for, all of them road-tested in my home made brownie combine to point out off their variations in taste, shade, and richness. Observe that you could typically get monetary savings by shopping for in bulk—like every cocoa, Dutch kinds are shelf-stable and might usually be saved for years, so long as they’re protected against daylight in an hermetic container at cool room temperature. When doubtful, seek the advice of the expiration date from the producer; it would usually be a yr or two from the date of buy.
Nu Naturals
This fair-trade Dutch cocoa falls into the vary of 22 to 24% cocoa butter, which is greater than twice the fats of most grocery store choices. Whereas it has a deep chocolate taste, it is not as earthy as different manufacturers, permitting among the cocoa’s fruitiness to tug via.
In brownies, it baked up unexpectedly darkish, given its comparatively mild shade. The taste-testers at Severe Eats discovered these brownies to be the chewiest of the lot, maybe owing to the cocoa’s explicit stability of fats, starch, and pH. At 87 cents per ounce, it is a terrific worth for any baker on the lookout for a multipurpose Dutch cocoa that will not break the financial institution.

Cacao Barry Further Brute
One other Dutch cocoa within the 22-to-24% vary, Cacao Barry Further Brute is wealthy and fragrant. The corporate sources its beans from international locations in West Africa and makes use of a fermentation and drying course of that provides to the complexity of taste.

This model has been my private go-to for years; its deep shade and richness lend a darkish chocolate punch to any recipe. It is bought in bigger packages than many different manufacturers, exemplifying the worth of bulk buying at simply 56 cents an oz..
Callebaut CP777
Made with a mix of beans from West Africa, in addition to from Central and South America, Callebaut’s CP777 has a well-rounded chocolate taste that is basic however advanced.

At almost $1.20 an oz., it is on the pricier finish, so think about it one thing of a special-occasion splurge. Whereas its fats content material likewise falls between 22 and 24%, it made brownies that appeared notably gooey and wealthy, so we suspect it is on the upper finish of that spectrum.
Bensdorp Royal Dutch
Bensdorp is a Dutch chocolate firm with a 175-year-old custom to its identify. Its “Royal Dutch” model of cocoa makes use of West Africa–sourced beans which are extra darkly alkalized than many different kinds, giving it a gorgeously darkish shade and earthy taste.

This cocoa additionally has an particularly nice grind, which lends a shiny sheen in brownies and good solubility in functions like sizzling cocoa.
Droste
At 20% fats, Droste is slightly leaner than among the different Dutch cocoa powders right here, nevertheless it was a sleeper hit in our blind tasting. Although it isn’t fancy, there’s nothing to complain about in its earthy chocolate taste. As a result of it is comparatively straightforward to search out in supermarkets and semi-fancy groceries alike, Droste is certainly one of my most well-liked selections after I’m between shipments on manufacturers that require a particular order on-line, so I used to be happy to see it carry out so effectively with our tasters.

Comfort issue apart, shopping for in bulk on-line can assist drive down the price per ounce compared with the retail markup you get in shops.
Valrhona
When you will not see the phrase “Dutch” on the packaging of this French cocoa, nor any point out of alkalization, we have been assured by representatives from Valrhona that its cocoa is certainly alkalized. It is a cocoa powder favored by professionals, with a daring taste owing to the corporate’s excessive requirements in sourcing and manufacture—and it is acquired a price ticket to match.

When purchased in half-pound containers, Valrhona is sort of $2 an oz.. If you happen to’re severe about your cocoa powder, my advice is to spend extra up entrance to purchase in bulk and both cut up the order with a number of baking buddies or sit again and know you’ll be effectively stocked for years. It will drive the price down to simply 65 cents an oz., an incredible worth for such a high-end cocoa. It made a wealthy, darkish, and shiny brownie that was Vicky’s high choose.
In the end, deciding on the “greatest” cocoa is a fairly private endeavor, however attempting completely different kinds and types is one of the simplest ways to raised perceive your individual preferences and baking model. If nothing else, these cocoas supply an opportunity to discover your favourite recipes in a brand new mild, to see how one ingredient can influence the flavour general.

This publish could include hyperlinks to Amazon or different companions; your purchases by way of these hyperlinks can profit Severe Eats. Learn extra about our affiliate linking coverage.